Vertical farming

Agriculture grows up

Scroll to continue

Some experts fear the triple whammy of climate change, urbanisation and population rise will result in catastrophic global hunger by the middle of this century. One possible solution is vertical farming. Ian Valentine asks if it’s time for agriculture to grow up.

Dickson Despommier, professor of microbiology and public health at the University of Columbia, New York City, never tires of talking about his favourite subject. Recognised as the father of vertical farming – today, a fast-expanding industry where fruit and vegetables are grown in high-rise buildings rather than traditional rural fields or greenhouses – he recalls the moment the penny dropped in 1999.

“We were in the classroom, discussing the causes and possible solutions of climate change, and my students got downhearted. They said they felt powerless to make a difference. So, they embarked on a six-month practical to calculate how many Manhattans could be fed, if all of the borough’s rooftops were dedicated to gardening.”

Just two percent, was their answer. Negligible. Despommier tried to pick his students up off the floor. “It’s a good start,” he said, off the cuff. “But what if the interiors of those buildings were handed over to production too? How many people could be fed then?” He admits that question has consumed his thoughts ever since. 


Among the many academic books Despommier has written is The Vertical Farm: Feeding the World in the 21st Century. While he is not the only one to have championed the idea of urban farming, his enthusiasm, and his moniker, ‘vertical farming’, have given it a platform at a time when consumers and entrepreneurs are looking for alternatives to traditional agriculture. “This has gathered momentum because the planet is showing clear signs of disease,” he explains. “Mankind is now struggling to produce crops in once fertile lands that have become barren because of the changing climate. Look at how the monsoon patterns have shifted in southeast Asia or the Far East, for example, causing whole farming communities to fail, and then move to the cities. Millions of people have gone from producers to consumers in just a generation.”

As an academic, Despommier has scant commercial interest in outcompeting outdoor farmers. He sees his mission entirely in climate change terms. “If traditional agriculture was doing well, vertical farming would never have taken off,” he maintains. “The burning question for the human species is: what are we going to do when it’s no longer possible to grow the amount of food that we’ve grown before? What happens in a few decades’ time when there are 10 billion mouths to feed?”

On paper, certainly, the potential benefits of urban farming are compelling. Imagine year-round crop production, in which all four seasons guarantee a bumper harvest. Weather becomes irrelevant. Water can be saved and re-used. Desert, arctic or tropical regions can become self-sufficient in lettuces or chickpeas. No pesticides, fertilisers, or herbicides. No toxic agricultural runoff. No need for shipping or storage. New employment opportunities in neglected city areas, which often have a surplus of abandoned properties. Clear opportunities for wind, solar, tidal, and geothermal energy.

Above: Dickson Despommier is one of the world's experts on vertical farming, and author of The Vertical Farm: Feeding the World in the 21st Century.

Imagine year-round crop production, in which all four seasons guarantee a bumper harvest.

“Rather than scattering seeds and hoping for the best, farmers can control the temperature, humidity, wavelengths of light and amount of nutrients that each seed receives, leading to much higher survivability and yields,” Despommier adds.

All over the world, agricultural companies are experimenting with different types of vertical farms. In Sweden, Plantagon is developing farming systems inside basements, car parks, offices and factories. In the United States, Modular Farms offers customers a complete indoor vertical farming system capable of producing fresh plants in virtually any climate. Such is the pace of change, even this disruptive industry is being disrupted. German innovator Aponix, for example, is touting barrel-shaped planters to replace the standard horizontal tubs.

Despommier accepts there are challenges to overcome. Vertical farmers aren’t bothered by aphids, slugs or locusts, but there are other factors that can eat into their profit margins. 

Unless the cost of electricity is below ten US cents per kWh, for example, then vertical farming isn’t environmentally or economically viable. Labour is another concern, especially as farms may be forced to hire expensive locals rather than cheap migrant workers if they want the authorities’ permission to develop abandoned properties.

The other hurdle is crop diversity. Farmers may need to expand their growing configurations to offer a much wider variety of plants to meet consumer tastes, even if some of those prove less profitable.

Having shouted from the rooftops about vertical farming, Despommier is now enjoying more of an armchair ride, as others have taken on the loud-hailer. Technical improvements have far exceeded his imagination, while he has also lost track of the number of new facilities worldwide. “I’m sort of dazed that an idea which started in a classroom in 1999 has germinated into a robust and growing industry by 2018. I get a huge sense of satisfaction from that.”

What no soil?

AeroFarms, based in Newark, New Jersey, USA, includes the world’s largest vertical farm among its nine facilities worldwide. Stacked up high in a former steel mill, a paintball arena and a defunct nightclub – all on major distribution routes and near population centres – their tubs yield 390 times more per square metre annually than outdoor farms. They like to call themselves “beyond organic”, because they don’t use natural pesticides – they use zero pesticides. AeroFarms claims the magic comes from what they call an aeroponic growing system that mists the roots of plants with nutrients, water, and oxygen, requiring 95 per cent less water than standard farms, and 40 per cent less than hydroponics. LED lights create a specific light recipe for each plant, giving them exactly the spectrum, intensity and frequency they need for photosynthesis in the most energy-efficient way possible. Monitored by real-time data, this engineered lighting allows farmers to control the size, shape, texture, colour, flavour and nutrition of plants with razor-sharp precision and increased productivity.

Are you sure you want to remove this article from your library?